SHOOTERS' RIGHTS ASSOCIATION

For shooters and re-enactors, living history demonstrators, air soft players etc. Membership benefits include

the Shooters' Journal, advice line and £10 million VCR compliant PLI as standard for all activities 

Blog

Blog

Panorama - Monday

Posted on August 18, 2018 at 4:50 AM

Panorama - BBC One Monday 20th at 20.30 BST 'legal weapon'. This arises from RFD Paul Edmunds buying obsolete calibre revolvers in the US and selling them with homemade ammunition to the scrote community, for which he got a 30-year sentence last November. The Beeb have been sitting on this programme for months waiting for another case to hit the courts - and that case ended on Wednesday with the dealer acquitted. Edmunds was a one-off rogue dealer, judging by the number of his 'associates' to have been rolled over by the police and come up clean. The Law Commission have recommended that antique firearms should not change hands for cash - a restriction that has applied to the scrap metal trade for sometime - and the Policing and Crime Act 2017 empowered the Home Office to introduce regulations to define an antique: which they haven’t yet. That's at the heart of this: the first Firearms Act in 1920 exempted antiques from controls, subject to being possessed solely as curiosities or ornaments. These two words had been used in conjunction with each other to advertise 'Exchange and Mart' magazine (founded 1878) in other publications, so in 1920 everyone knew what they meant. The landmark prosecution was Richards v Curwen in 1977 - which acquitted him of possessing two early mark (1890s) Webley revolvers. To be an antique, the firearm has to be kept as a curiosity or ornament after which its obsolescence by age is the question of fact and degree. The court rejected the prosecution argument that the Webleys used 'modern' ammunition on the basis that using ammunition type as a definition would mean they'd never become antiques, but also said that 20th century firearms probably wouldn’t be antiques. Naturally, the Home Office ignored the Court of Appeal and continued to rely on ammunition as defining antique versus modern. The secret memorandum of guidance to police (1969) suggested that obsolete ignition systems were antiques and carried that thinking through to the published version in 1989 with advice that possession of ammunition might indicate that something wasn’t a curiosity or ornament. Then in 1992, pressured by the passage of time, came the obsolete calibre list. That caused some prosecutions: one of our members had a collection of Martini Henry rifles on the wall and one on his firearm certificate for target shooting. So when the police rolled him, he was prosecuted for all the antiques because he had ammunition. They dropped that at the court door. Most of the prosecutions I dealt with (as an expert witness) were people who kept old guns as curiosities or ornaments and the prosecution challenge was that the stuff couldn’t be antique because it took ‘modern ammunition’. Acquittals included a pre-1893 .410” shotgun, a 12 bore 1910 Greener GP, loads of black powder proofed hammer shotguns and a few really old revolvers: all predating 1900, so the acquittals were in line with Richard v Curwen and the anomaly was the prosecutions – driven by guidance to the CPS that didn’t tell them how to decide whether to prosecute or not. In 1994 R v Brown, the Court of Appeal acquitted him – he had a .22” War Office pattern rifle – and said that time had moved on and so must the definition. Bill Harriman was the defence expert in that one. Prosecutors continued to apply guidance that did not take account of case law to their decisions. I had a case in which magistrates convicted a dude of all his collection – a Luger pistol, a 19th century blank firing single shot pistol and two flare pistols. These came to him as frames only: he made the stocks, trigger and locking latch and ‘barrelled’ them with copper tube. They looked quite smart, but the obsessive prosecution ‘expert’ insisted that they were lethal barrelled weapons. We didn’t appeal, as the magistrates gave him a conditional discharge and instructed police to give me the exhibits for deactivation so that the defendant could have them back. In another case, the exhibit was a Colt New Service revolver that had been changing hands round a shooting club for the previous 20 years or so. Police traced it back to when Army and Navy stores sold it new in 1915. The officer buyer gave it to his son for WW2 and he gave it to his daughter’s boyfriend in the 1970s – as he belonged to the club. The club secretary was convicted and fined £150. That was typical in such circumstances and remained so until the 2003 Anti-social Behaviour Act brought in a mandatory five-year sentence for possession of a prohibited small firearm. Handguns were banned in the UK in 1997. That had the effect of making a defence of ‘antique’ a bigger deal, because instead of £150 fines, five years inside would be a life changing experience. Our early experience of antiques cases post 2003 was prosecutions being dropped if a robust antique status argument was put up. These mostly related to obsolete calibres that weren’t on the Home office list. That list didn’t include .320, for example until the 2003 revision and still doesn’t include .455” – the ammunition that the Richards v Curwen revolvers (1977 acquittal) took. Then attitudes hardened – we think that the Home Office needed convictions for old tat to make gun crime look as though it were on the up. Juries didn’t want to convict collectors of obsolete stuff with a five year gaol term in the offing: significant acquittals included a 1942 Lanchester submachine gun and a 1946 Inglis Browning GP35 – David Dyson was the defence expert in those cases. That got the Law Commission into paranoid overdrive and led to clauses in the Policing and Crime Act 2017. Meanwhile, Paul Edmunds was buying old revolvers in the US, making the cartridges and selling into the black market. The case against the section 5 dealer that finished Wednesday started in January 2016 with police burning the electronic locks off his driveway gates. More than thirty police vehicles convoyed in to disgorge over 100 policemen who searched the house in the presence of his young family. He had a small antiques collection and was charged with possessing them without the authority of the secretary of state (which he has) on the strength of ammunition in his armoury might be suitable for use in them. Such is the paranoid obsession that drives the Home Office. Separating firearms licensing from the police and Home Office to a competent agency is long overdue in the UK. The jury acquitted him after the traditional two-hour lunch break. So what now? We’ll have to watch the programme and see. RL

Categories: None

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

7616 Comments

Reply HarryGok
11:32 AM on March 11, 2020 
buy viagra turkey http://viaph24.com - cheap viagra viagra pro order now
Reply fosyday
1:38 PM on March 11, 2020 
cheap-generic-viagra.co.uk http://viaph24.com - viagra generic availability buy levitra bayer
Reply RobertSaulk
4:22 PM on March 11, 2020 
mail order viagra uk http://levph24.com - levitra 20 mg legal buy viagra online uk
Reply DavidSoify
5:36 PM on March 11, 2020 
buy viagra online legally http://viaph24.com - viagra without doctor prescription best place to order generic cialis
Reply JamesEndaw
6:26 PM on March 11, 2020 
can cialis pills be split in half http://ciaph24.com - cialis online buy brand name levitra online
Reply queelmTal
6:59 PM on March 11, 2020 
how to order cialis online safely http://levph24.com - generic levitra vardenafil buy viagra doha
Reply Wetainape
9:59 PM on March 11, 2020 
buy liquid cialis http://levph24.com - levitra prices order cialis online uk
Reply gatinue
10:43 PM on March 11, 2020 
buy excel herbal viagra http://levph24.com - levitra 20 mg generic cialis online
Reply HarryGok
10:49 PM on March 11, 2020 
buy viagra legally uk http://levph24.com - levitra generic buy cheap viagra mexico
Reply Nuxuche
3:24 AM on March 12, 2020 
viagra for sale online http://viaph24.com - viagra viagra online canada
Reply kitnette
3:28 AM on March 12, 2020 
buy cialis tablets uk http://ciaph24.com - generic cialis buy levitra uk online
Reply JamesEndaw
4:25 AM on March 12, 2020 
buy cialis from canadian pharmacy http://levph24.com - levitra cheapest generic viagra
Reply fosyday
5:43 AM on March 12, 2020 
buy cialis in vancouver http://ciaph24.com - cialis cost cheap viagra online usa
Reply queelmTal
6:09 AM on March 12, 2020 
cheap viagra canada http://viaph24.com - viagra without doctor prescription how to order viagra in australia
Reply DavidSoify
6:41 AM on March 12, 2020 
viagra sale melbourne http://viaph24.com - viagra without a doctor prescription viagra sale phone
Reply HarryGok
9:10 AM on March 12, 2020 
generic viagra buy canada http://viaph24.com - generic viagra 100mg buy cialis boots
Reply RobertSaulk
9:38 AM on March 12, 2020 
buy cialis new delhi http://viaph24.com - viagra without a doctor prescription viagra buy india
Reply Wetainape
12:10 PM on March 12, 2020 
viagra sale non prescription http://levph24.com - levitra online buy viagra nhs
Reply axivqiecaiq
2:12 PM on March 12, 2020 
http://mewkid.net/when-is-xaxlop/ - Amoxicillin Without Prescription Amoxicillin 500 Mg czn.lhml.isabelacera.com.ais.hb http://mewkid.net/when-is-xaxlop/
Reply JamesEndaw
2:13 PM on March 12, 2020 
viagra buy mastercard http://ciaph24.com - cialis online cheap viagra quick delivery